The Top 10 Best Car Insurance Wisconsin For 2023

All Wisconsin car owners need car insurance, but finding the right coverage that fits their satisfaction can be challenging. People can make the task easier by focusing their search on the best car insurance Wisconsin providers. 

In this article, we will be talking about the best car insurance in Wisconsin.


  • You will learn about the cost of car insurance in WISCONSIN per month.
  • You will learn about the best Insurance in Wisconsin.
  • Each Insurance has its cons and pros written out for you.
  • Answers to some frequently asked questions on the best car insurance in Wisconsin.
best car insurance Wisconsin

The Top 10 Best Car Insurance Wisconsin For 2023

Vehicle insurance is Insurance for motorcycles, cars, trucks, and other road vehicles. Vehicle insurance’s primary use is to provide financial protection against bodily injury or physical damage resulting from traffic collisions and against liability that might arise from incidents in a vehicle.

Car insurance covers damage to people’s vehicles and protects them financially if they are liable for someone else’s injuries or damagesWhen people purchase car insurance, they can pay their premium for the year upfront or in monthly increments.

Most insurance companies allow people to set up automatic payments with credit or debit cards. Still, they may also be able to pay through a money order, a check, or an electronic funds transfer that will directly deposit money from their bank to their insurer.

The Top 10 Best Car Insurance Wisconsin 

According to some studies, Wisconsin’s average auto insurance rate is $1,175 per year. It is said to be lower than the national average of $1,442 per year and the lowest average among surrounding states.

Check Out Other Reads:

The Top 10 Best Car Insurance Wisconsin 

 Below is a list of the top 10 best car insurance in Wisconsin.

1. State Farm 

State Farm insurance has been around for close to a century, and today the Insurance is one of the country’s most popular car and home insurance providers. The insurance company offers unique options and features that drivers can take advantage of. These features include:

  • Low rates for young drivers: Research shows that young drivers, on average, can find good and affordable car insurance coverage through State Farm insurance. The insurance company offers a telematics insurance program and discounts to bring down costs for people who lack driving experience.
  • Strong industry and customer service reputation: State Farm Insurance has a good customer service reputation and strong industry ratings shown in the J.D. Power studies.
  • Variety of coverage options: With State Farm insurance, drivers can purchase standard car insurance coverage and roadside assistance, travel expense, rental car reimbursement, and rideshare insurance.


  • Good discount opportunities for teens and students.
  • Usage-based insurance discount
  • The company has many local insurance agents across the U.S.


  • Not available in Rhode Island or Massachusetts.

2. Geico 

The Geico insurance company is a good insurance company for some drivers. It ties for 3rd place alongside State Farm.

According to some data analysis from our study, the insurance company has average scores in policy renewals, claims handling, customer service, customer recommendations, and customer loyalty. 


  • The company offers low rates for drivers with poor credit 
  • 2nd lowest average rates compared to other insurance companies in this list.


  • The rates for drivers with a DUI are higher than the average rates.

3. Nationwide 

The Nationwide insurance company offers different Insurance and financial products. If people prefer to bundle insurance products with a financially strong company, the Nationwide insurance company might be a good fit.


  • Fewer complaints to
  • state regulators for auto insurance.
  • Wide variety of
  • options for clients who want to buy multiple products from one company.


  • Customer satisfaction

4. Progressive 

The country’s 3rd-largest car insurance company is Progressive insurance company. The company offers Insurance for just about anything with a motor. The company offers a wide range of coverage for pets injured in a car accident, rideshare insurance, and a lengthy slate of discounts.


  • 3rd-largest personal car insurer in the country.
  • Pet injury insurance is included in most states if people buy collision coverage.
  • Rideshare coverage is available.


  • Below-average rating
  • For auto insurance shopping customer satisfaction from J.D. Power.

5. Erie

The Erie Insurance company is a strong choice for Insurance. The company operates in 12 states and Washington, D.C., and makes most customers happy: Erie generally gets high marks for satisfaction in J.D. Power ratings. The insurance company, unlike most insurance companies, offers the following:

New car replacement: If people have a car up to 2 years old and it’s totaled, the Erie company will replace it with a new car of the current model year, minus the deductible. 

Better car replacement: If people’s car is at least 2 years old and is totaled, the insurance company will pay for a car of the same make and model 2 years newer, minus the deductible. 


  • Low customer
  • complaints for car insurance.
  • Many perks and
  • coverage options.
  • Option to lock in
  • auto insurance rate.


  • Not available in most states.


The USAA insurance company offers a wide variety of insurance products and gets high reviews in customer satisfaction surveys.

According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, customers can invest and bank through the USAA insurance company, which is the country’s 5th-largest car insurer.

The USAA insurance company only sells car insurance to active military members, veterans, and their families.


  • High customer
  • satisfaction ratings for car insurance.
  • One-stop shop for
  • Insurance as well as banking/investing products.
  • Policies available in all states.


Available to active military, veterans, and their families only.

7. Secura

The cost of auto insurance at the SECURA insurance company remains fairly affordable at every coverage level compared to the average insurance company, though it’s never the most affordable provider.

Drivers with a previous accident on their record find that SECURA Insurance gives them the best rates, even compared to larger providers.


  • Buying a combined home and car insurance policy
  • The company reduces the cost of car insurance with discounts


  • Purchasing great standalone car coverage
  • Getting highly rated customer service

8. Hastings Mutuals

The Hastings Mutual insurance company has an extremely well-established carrier with over 130 years of experience in the insurance industry.

The company provides coverage for businesses, individuals, and farmers, including auto and home insurance, commercial umbrella insurance, farm owners insurance, and more. A.M. Best and the BBB highly rate the insurance company. 


  • The Insurance Company focuses on providing A+ customer service to clients and promoting strong relationships with its clients.
  • The company has 130 years of service and has built a good reputation among its clients.
  • The company has affordable rates.
  • Offers Multi-Policy discounts.


  • The coverage is available in only 6 midwestern states across the U.S.
  • The insurance company doesn’t offer an online application; people need to call an agent for a quote.

9. Acuity 

The Acuity Insurance company was established in 1925 and had decades of expertise in providing great insurance plans and services to people and businesses.

The Acuity Insurance company has earned a reputation for being a reliable corporation. While coverage is unavailable in every state, the carrier works with more than 1,000 independent agencies nationwide.


  • The company offers quick responses to customers
  • The company provides lots of extra coverage
  • Ensures the best customer satisfaction


  • The availability of Insurance is limited to 21 states.

10. American Family

The American Family Insurance company is a mid-level insurance company designed for people looking for affordable and comprehensive auto coverage and people who want to bundle auto and home policies.

People can access American Family Insurance’s discounts by bundling different types of coverage. The insurance company offers diminishing deductible plans and a tool that helps people find repair shops.


  • Offers competitive prices
  • Diminishing deductible insurance
  • Bundle discounts


  • Available in 19 states
  • Services can be confusing


The 7 Best Malpractice Insurance For Nurse Practitioners

15 Best Car Insurance In Australia 2023

The 7 Best Independent Contractor Insurance In Australia


To help people choose the best insurance company they need, Coin decimal has helped analyze insurance companies based on claims satisfaction, customer satisfaction, and financial strength to make it easier for people to choose from. The insurance company was scored according to data from J.D. Power and AM Best.


Which car will have the cheapest Insurance?

  • Ford Escape ($1,427 annually).
  • Mazda CX-5 ($1,412 annually).
  • Jeep Wrangler ($1,406 annually).
  • Hyundai Tucson ($1,406 annually)
  • Honda CR-V ($1,359 annually).
  • Subaru Forester ($1,347 annually).
  • Subaru Outback ($1,336 annually).

Is car insurance high in Wisconsin?

According to some studies, Wisconsin’s average auto insurance rate is $1,175 per year. It is said to be lower than the national average of $1,442 per year and the lowest average among surrounding states.

What is the average car Insurance for Wisconsin?

 The average rate of auto insurance in Wisconsin is $1,169 per year.

Is car insurance mandatory in Wisconsin?

Yes. All Wisconsin car owners must have a car insurance policy in force or, in limited situations, other security that could be personal funds, surety bonds, or a certificate of self-insurance when operating a car in Wisconsin.

You can learn more from the video below:

Get Latest Market Updates!

Enter your name & email to get started!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Sharing is caring...

Leave a Comment